Sierra Club Opposes Building Another Power Plant at Ft. Martin yet PILOT Plan is on the Mon County Agenda

by admin on December 14, 2020

The facts are in on Climate Change, but not at the Mon County Commission

WV Sierra Club’s conservation chairman shares thoughts on PILT agreements

From an Article by Ben Conley, Morgantown Dominion Post, Dec. 13, 2020

James Kotcon, Conservation Committee Chairman for the West Virginia Sierra Club, deferred to the Great One when asked his thoughts on the pending 30-year “payment in lieu of taxes” (PILT) agreement between the Monongalia County Board of Education, the Monongalia County Commission and daughter companies of Longview Power.

The agreement will allow for the placement of solar array fields generating about 70 megawatts, 20 of which will come from 127 acres of solar arrays in West Virginia. The rest will be placed in Pennsylvania.

The Sierra Club has no issue with this solar facility.

The agreement will also allow for the construction of a 1,200 megawatt combined cycle gas facility powered by two high-efficiency, low-heat-rate gas turbines.

The Sierra Club has issues with this natural gas fired plant.

“I’m reminded of a quote from the hockey superstar (Great One) Wayne Gretzky, who said that I skate to where the puck is going to be,” Kotcon said. “So if we want to invest in the energy of the future, natural gas is 10 years out of date already. That industry is as likely to disappear as fast as the coal industry is.”

Kotcon said he was pleased to see the PILT planning is actually as two agreements, one for the solar facility and another for the gas facility.

“That is useful because we think that addressing greenhouse gasses as aggressively as the world needs to means the Longview plant probably will not be burning natural gas for the 30-year period contemplated by this PILT agreement,” Kotcon said. “President-elect Biden has proposed a clean electric grid, carbon neutral, by 2035, so within 15 years.”

On the other hand, a lot of items were not included in the agreement that the Sierra Club has pushed for, including specific controls on pollutants like carbon dioxide emissions.

The Sierra Club has also called on the commission to include protections in case the cost of the project ends up being more than the $1.1 billion projection.

Kotcon said the original Longview PILT agreement, which paved the way for the company’s existing coal-fired power plant, was negotiated when the cost of the project was anticipated to be around $960 million. It ended up north of $2 billion.

“There doesn’t seem to be anything in these agreements that would help insulate the county should Longview be as wrong this time as they were last time,” he said.

The Sierra Club has been outspoken in opposition to what it sees as a tax deal for fossil fuels. The group made its case to the West Virginia Public Service Commission, which approved the projects in April.

The agreements, which were approved by the Board of Education and will be before the commission Wednesday, would provide the county $58.2 million over 30 years.

The facility agreements and lease and PILT documents are available upon request at info@moncommission.com.

#####. #####. #####. #####. #####.

SELECTED REFERENCE: Natural gas accelerates climate change through alarming methane emissions, Energy Watch Group, September 17, 2019

Conversion from coal and oil to natural gas can result in an overall increase in the greenhouse effect of energy consumption by up to 40%.

{ 1 comment… read it below or add one }

Mary Wildfire December 14, 2020 at 8:49 am

This really pisses me off. Is there any way I can comment? I don’t subscribe to DP so I can’t comment there.

All over the world, people in positions of authority are making decisions like this, carefully adjusting their blinders to avoid seeing what it isn’t politic to see. Like that getting money for your schools by permitting yet another fossil fuel facility is pointless, as your actions are foreclosing the kind of future the kids would need an education for.

The schools should be teaching about hand combat, emergency shelter, purifying drinking water since the authorities, including the school board, are setting up the kind of future in which warlord-led gangs, famine, fire, flood, drought, pestilence and breakdown are the norms and survival is the objective.

This kind of criminal irresponsibility is absolutely normal, nearly universal, and it’s why activists are saying, flatly– capitalism is not compatible with adequate action on climate change.

I have a grandchild going to school in Morgantown.

Mary Wildfire, Roane County, WV

Reply

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: